Which is a better first car?

These cars are not ideal as a first car. Your insurance premium will be sky-high. The best would be the 2006 Pat but I would look at a Volkswagen Polo or a Skoda Fabia. These cars are cheap to run (petrol/road tax/insurance), and you will get a low mileage car for the money. You don't want a car with 60k+, it'll start goi ng wrong.